Bednar
Photo by Claudette Alcober, ONNJ Sports
November 18, 2026

David Bednar’s Record-Setting Qualifying Offer Acceptance Comes With a Catch

By Jonna Perlinger

The Yankees secured their closer for 2027, but his historic salary comes with significant financial implications as Brian Cashman continues rebuilding the bullpen.

The New York Yankees won’t have to spend their offseason searching for a closer after all.

On Tuesday, David Bednar accepted the Yankees’ one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer, securing his return to the Bronx for the 2027 season and making MLB history in the process.

The deal gives Bednar the highest single-season average annual value (AAV) ever awarded to a relief pitcher, surpassing the $23 million AAV of Edwin Díaz’s previous contract with the New York Mets.

It’s a significant investment for a team already facing payroll concerns, but one that eliminates arguably the biggest question surrounding New York’s bullpen.

And with general manager Brian Cashman identifying relief pitching as his biggest offseason priority, the Yankees have already made considerable progress.

Yankees make historic investment in David Bednar

Bednar’s decision comes as somewhat of a surprise, considering the two-time All-Star was expected to attract significant interest on the open market.

Upon extending the qualifying offer to Bednar, they faced the possibility of losing their closer to a team willing to offer a lucrative multi-year contract.

Instead, Bednar opted for the guaranteed $23.15 million payday, providing New York with another season of stability in the ninth inning without a long-term commitment.

And his production certainly supports the investment.

Bednar finished 2026 with a 7-3 record, converting 35 of 39 save opportunities while posting a 2.47 ERA, 1.04 WHIP and 76 strikeouts across 69 1/3 innings.

The 32-year-old also recorded the most saves by a Yankees pitcher in a single season since Aroldis Chapman collected 37 in 2019.

Since arriving from the Pittsburgh Pirates at the 2025 trade deadline, Bednar has provided precisely the kind of reliability New York had been missing at the back end of its bullpen.

Now Cashman can direct his attention toward strengthening the arms responsible for getting the ball to him.

Bednar’s deal pushes Yankees further into luxury-tax territory

Of course, securing Bednar’s services comes at a considerable price.

His $23.15 million salary is projected to push New York’s luxury-tax payroll beyond $300 million for 2027, placing the Yankees well above the $244 million competitive balance tax threshold established for 2026.

With MLB’s current collective bargaining agreement set to expire December 1, the luxury-tax structure for 2027 remains uncertain. However, the Yankees are already positioning themselves for another expensive season.

That creates an interesting situation for managing general partner Hal Steinbrenner, who has repeatedly expressed his belief that winning a World Series shouldn’t require a $300 million payroll.

Yet the Yankees have made another substantial financial commitment before addressing several other roster needs.

The good news is that Bednar’s deal carries no financial obligation beyond 2027.

The downside is that allocating more than $23 million to a single reliever could influence how aggressively Cashman pursues additional bullpen help, a right-handed catcher or upgrades elsewhere on the roster.

And New York still has plenty of work to do.

Yankees aren’t finished rebuilding their bullpen

Bednar isn’t the only familiar face returning to the Bronx.

On Sunday, New York agreed to bring back veteran left-hander Tim Hill on a one-year, $2.25 million contract that includes a $2.5 million club option for 2028.

While Hill struggled at times in 2026, finishing with a 4.60 ERA, he led all MLB relievers with a 68.9% ground-ball rate and allowed just two of 35 inherited runners to score.

Those numbers demonstrate why the Yankees still value his ability to generate ground balls and escape difficult situations.

And Cashman apparently isn’t finished pursuing bullpen reunions.

According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the Yankees also intend to bring back Paul Blackburn, who became one of the club’s most dependable relievers after transitioning into a full-time bullpen role.

Blackburn finished the season with an impressive 1.54 ERA across 82 relief innings, providing New York with another reliable late-inning option.

The Yankees finished 2026 with a 3.13 bullpen ERA, the second-best mark in baseball.

But much of that success depended on enormous workloads from Blackburn and Brent Headrick, who appeared in 81 games and posted a 2.18 ERA.

Simply bringing back the same pitchers and expecting identical results isn’t necessarily ta reliable approach.

The Yankees could still benefit from another high-leverage reliever, particularly one capable of generating strikeouts and reducing the pressure on their existing arms.

Cashman’s biggest priority is taking shape

With Bednar and Hill secured and Blackburn potentially next, the Yankees are making progress on the area Cashman identified as his biggest offseason concern.

And doing so before the current CBA expires on December 1 provides some much-needed certainty amid the possibility of a work stoppage.

But Bednar’s historic contract also raises the stakes.

New York has already committed significant money to maintaining a bullpen that performed well throughout the regular season, and the organization still has several weaknesses to address following another disappointing postseason exit.

Retaining Bednar was the right move. The Yankees weren’t going to find a better internal option to close games, and replacing his production through free agency could have required an even longer financial commitment.

But spending $23.15 million on a closer shouldn’t mean settling for the same supporting cast.

Cashman has his ninth-inning answer. Now he needs to make sure the Yankees are better equipped to get there.

About the Author

Jonna Perlinger
Jonna Perlinger
Social Media Director, Baseball Content Lead, New York Yankees Lead Writer

Jonna Perlinger is the Social Media Director, Baseball Content Lead, and Lead Yankees Writer for ONNJsports.com, where she directs social media initiatives, oversees baseball coverage, and handles the editing and publishing of her own content. She is also a contributing writer for Sports Illustrated’s Yankees on SI.

Raised in a diehard Yankees family, Jonna Perlinger has been around baseball her entire life. At six years old, she received a broken bat from Buck Showalter, just as the Yankees’ legendary 1990s dynasty was beginning. That bat would make countless trips to school for show-and-tell over the years. She’s been writing about the Yankees since grade school, with her mom still holding onto many of those earliest publications.

Jonna is also the founder of Babe’s Babes Media, a women-led baseball media platform dedicated to amplifying women’s voices in the sport. Beyond Major League Baseball, she covers Division I college baseball and has reported from the College World Series, NCAA Regionals, and Super Regionals.

Follow her on X @90syankskid | Instagram @babesbabes_baseball | BZZR @JP_YankeesGirl

Related News