Gotham's Tierna Davidson (first standing from left), Jordynn Dudley (third), and Ann-Katrin Berger (fourth) (Photo by Beshoy Erian, ONNJ Sports)
November 18, 2026

Dudley, Berger Headline Gotham FC’s Showing at 2026 NWSL Awards

By David Macaulay-Smith

Gotham FC’s 2026 season produced its first NWSL Shield and another Challenge Cup trophy. On Wednesday, the league recognized the individuals who helped make that success possible, with six Gotham players earning honors at the NWSL Awards in Washington, D.C.

Jordynn Dudley was named the 2026 NWSL Rookie of the Year, while Ann-Katrin Berger claimed Goalkeeper of the Year for the second time in three seasons. Berger also earned a place on the Best XI First Team alongside defender Tierna Davidson and midfielder Jaelin Howell. Rose Lavelle was named to the Second Team.

For Dudley, the award capped a debut professional season in which she quickly became one of Gotham’s most dangerous attacking options. She is the third player in club history to win Rookie of the Year in four seasons, joining Jenna Nighswonger (2023) and Lilly Reale (2025). Her recognition also gives Gotham consecutive winners of the award.

Dudley finished the regular season with four goals and three assists in 25 appearances, including 20 starts. Three of her goals were game-winners, including both strikes in a 2-1 victory over the North Carolina Courage, where she recorded the first brace of her professional career. She also scored in Gotham’s 2-0 Challenge Cup final victory over the Kansas City Current.

Her ability to take defenders on made her particularly difficult to contain. Dudley completed 41 dribbles, the most among rookies and third-most in the league. She also drew 61 fouls, more than any other player in the NWSL, including a league-leading 21 in the final third.

After receiving the award, Dudley credited the people who helped her reach the professional level.

“I want to thank all my teammates for getting me this far,” Dudley said. “And also my parents, who have always supported me throughout my journey.”

Gotham president of soccer operations Yael Averbuch West praised the forward’s immediate impact and the confidence she brought to the attack.

“What Jordynn has accomplished in her first professional season is incredibly impressive,” Averbuch West said. “She came into a highly competitive environment and immediately showed that she could make a difference at this level. Her fearlessness in the attack and ability to create opportunities have been exciting to watch, and we believe she has a very bright future ahead of her.”

Berger’s latest recognition was a continuation of the standard she has established since arriving in New Jersey. The German international won Goalkeeper of the Year in 2024, her first season with Gotham, and became a two-time recipient after another standout campaign between the posts.

She recorded 11 clean sheets during the regular season, breaking her own club record of 10 set in 2025. Her 15 wins in 27 starts and 84 saves helped Gotham finish with the league’s best defensive record, conceding just 23 goals in 30 matches.

Berger also ranked second in the NWSL in expected goals saved, highlighting her ability to deliver when opponents managed to create dangerous chances.

Averbuch West credited the goalkeeper’s consistency and importance to the club’s success.

“Ann has set an extraordinary standard of excellence in goal throughout her career, and this season has been another example of that,” Averbuch West said. “To earn this recognition for the second time in three years is a remarkable achievement. Her performances have been instrumental to our success, and we are thrilled to see her receive this well-deserved honor.”

The Best XI selections further illustrated Gotham’s strength throughout the spine of the team. Davidson, the club captain, earned First Team recognition after recording three goals and an assist in 29 appearances. The three goals represented a career high for a regular season, with two proving to be game winners.

Howell joined her on the First Team after a season defined by consistency in midfield. She became the first player in Gotham history to start all 30 regular season matches, setting a club record with 2,593 minutes. Her 65 tackles won ranked second in the league, while her 96 attempted tackles ranked third.

Lavelle earned Second Team honors after recording four goals and three assists in 25 appearances. The reigning NWSL Championship MVP also completed 36 dribbles, eighth-most in the league, as she continued to influence Gotham’s attacking play.

Gotham finished the regular season with an (18-5-7) record and 61 points, securing the first Shield in club history. With the Challenge Cup also added to its trophy collection, the club’s six individual award selections provided another measure of the quality behind its successful campaign.

About the Author

David Macaulay-Smith
Gotham FC Lead Writer

Related News