The first of several offseason moves for Gotham FC was announced Wednesday, as defender Jess Carter is departing the club after 2 1/2 seasons to join Bay FC as a free agent.
Carter has signed a contract with Bay FC through the 2028 season, with an option for 2029, bringing her time in New Jersey to an end.
The England international joined Gotham from Chelsea in July 2024 and went on to become a regular in the club’s defense. She leaves with four major trophies, having helped Gotham win the 2025 NWSL Championship, the 2026 NWSL Shield, the NWSL Challenge Cup and the Concacaf W Champions Cup.
Carter made 83 appearances across all competitions for Gotham, including 77 starts, and accumulated 6,728 minutes. The club recorded 43 wins, 16 draws and 18 losses in matches in which she featured.
Her importance to the team continued throughout the 2026 campaign. Carter appeared in all 30 of Gotham’s regular season matches, playing more than 2,500 minutes as the club secured its first NWSL Shield.
She also started all three playoff matches during Gotham’s 2025 championship run. That title, combined with England’s European Championship victory earlier that year, made Carter the first player to win the UEFA Women’s European Championship and NWSL Championship in the same calendar year.
“Jess has been a big part of what we’ve accomplished as a club, and we’re very thankful for the contributions she’s made during her time here,” Gotham president of soccer operations Yael Averbuch West said. “She brought a wealth of experience to our back line and helped us compete for and win championships. We appreciate everything she’s given to Gotham FC and wish her the best.”
Carter expressed excitement about the opportunity to begin a new chapter in California.
“Coming to Bay FC is a new challenge, and that’s something I’m excited about,” Carter said. “I’ve been fortunate to be part of some successful teams, and I know how much work goes into winning. I’m looking forward to getting to know this group, earning the trust of my teammates and doing my part to help us move forward.”
Before arriving in the NWSL, Carter spent six seasons with Chelsea, winning five consecutive Women’s Super League (WSL) titles. She also won consecutive UEFA Women’s European Championships with England in 2022 and 2025.
Her move to Bay FC will reunite her with chief football officer Paul Green, who previously worked with her at Chelsea. Green highlighted Carter’s experience and familiarity with winning environments as reasons for bringing her to the club.
“Jess has consistently demonstrated her quality in championship-winning environments at both club and international level,” Green said. “Having worked with her at Chelsea, I’ve seen her development and the professionalism she brings every day. She will bring valuable experience to Bay FC, and we’re delighted to welcome her to the club.”
Carter now joins Bay FC ahead of the 2027 NWSL season after playing a significant role in Gotham’s success over the past 2 1/2 years.

















